Southern Conference Champions
| Year | Weight | Name |
| 1954 | 147 | Jeff Robertson |
| 177 | Miles Nowitsky | |
| HWT | Nick Servidio | |
| 1955 | 147 | Pannill Jones |
| 1956 | HWT | Dale Vaughn |
| 1957 | HWT | Don Basham |
| 1960 | 147 | Bryan Kane |
| 157 | Bill Daniels | |
| 1961 | 147 | Al Bamforth |
| 167 | Bill Daniels | |
| HWT | Dennis Merklinger | |
| 1962 | 177 | Tom Hill |
| 1965 | 177 | Don Taylor |
| 1967 | 177 | Don Taylor |
| 1968 | 137 | Steve Vaughn |
| 177 | Don Taylor | |
| HWT | Bob Biddle | |
| 1969 | 160 | Jack Kennedy |
| HWT | Bob Biddle | |
| 1971 | 190 | Jim Bailey |
| 1972 | 158 | Phil Smith |
| 190 | Jim Bailey | |
| 1976 | HWT | Ned Stepanovich |
| 1977 | 190 | John Vizzi |
| HWT | Ned Stepanovich |
|
| 1980 | 118 | Bobby Greenwood |
| 1982 | 177 | Steve Evans |
| 1984 | 126 | John Munno |
| 142 | John Ehrenberger | |
| HWT | John Long | |
| 1985 | 118 | Bob Zoeke |
| 158 | Jesse Waltz | |
| HWT | John Long | |
| 1986 | 150 | Ben Walker |
| 167 | Todd Arris | |
| 1987 | 142 | Jay Smaaladen |
| 167 | Todd Arris | |
| 1988 | 142 | Jay Smaaladen |
| 1989 | 177 | Erick Ames |
| 1990 | 142 | Steve Pitts |
| 158 | Mike Murray | |
| 1991 | 126 | Brian Mason |
| 158 | Jeff Clark | |
| 1992 | 126 | Brian Mason |
| 134 | Charlie Branch | |
| 1993 | 142 | Charlie Branch |
| 1994 | 142 | Charlie Branch* |
| 158 | Fred Barber | |
| HWT | Mark Wysong | |
| 1995 | 134 | Adam Mickiewicz |
| 142 | Charlie Branch | |
| 150 | Jeremy Ingram | |
| 158 | Kevin Johnson | |
| 1996 | 126 | Aaron Mickiewicz |
| 134 | Adam Mickiewicz | |
| 142 | Jason Foresman | |
| 150 | Reese Edgington | |
| HWT | Leslie Apedoe | |
| 1997 | 134 | Adam Mickiewicz |
| 150 | Jason Foresman | |
| HWT | Leslie Apedoe | |
| 1998 | 158 | Jarrod Fitzpatrick |
| 190 | Isaac Moore | |
| HWT | Leslie Apedoe | |
| 1999 | 197 | Isaac Moore |
| HWT | Leslie Apedoe* | |
| 2000 | 174 | Austen Palmer |
| 2001 | 149 | Adam Britt |
| 2002 | 157 | Adam Britt |
| 174 | Matt Erwin | |
| 2003 | 157 | Adam Britt |
| 2004 | 149 | Sam Alvarenga |
| 2007 | 197 | Corry Murray |
| 2008 | HWT | Josh Wine |
| 2009 | HWT | Josh Wine |
| 2011 | HWT | Josh Wine |
| *-Denotes All-American |
